Rezension
"Reading through Uprising of the Fools is its own pilgrimage through parallel universes. There is Vikash Singh's ethnographic narrative of the North Indian Hindu pilgrimage, and, along the way, are Singh's own explorations of the meaning of the process. The book invites a double-vision: looking from inside and outside at the ways of knowing that, for all the apparent differences, link the pilgrim and the reader together. A remarkably original and subtle intellectual adventure."-Paul Courtright, Emory University "Uprising of the Fools is wonderfully-and disturbingly-rich with insights drawn from impressive ethnographic research. For anyone interested in theories of religious practice, performance, and pilgrimage, this is a must-read."-Robert Wuthnow, Princeton University "In this theoretically sophisticated, beautifully descriptive, and emotionally moving book, Vikash Singh gives us a compelling analysis of a contemporary religious pilgrimage. Uprising of the Fools is essential reading for ethnographers, cultural sociologists, scholars of religion, globalization theorists, and psychoanalytic thinkers alike."-Thomas DeGloma, Hunter College and the Graduate Center of the City University of New York "In this perceptive and enlightening study of Haridwar's annual kanvariya festival, Vikash Singh conveys the struggles of north India's anonymous laboring men, and ultimately their strength and resilience. Readers with interests in religion, sociology, or politics will find it thought-provoking and valuable."-James G. Lochtefeld, Carthage College "Vikash Singh has written a richly detailed ethnography of a little-studied North Indian pilgrimage that draws from across Hindu sects. He offers a provocative argument about the forces driving the growth of popular Hindu rituals, to show how they are an increasingly important site of self-making and religious reform in India today."-Arvind Rajagopal, New York University "Vikash Singh's Uprising of the Fools is bound to become a classic in the contemporary study of religion and sociology, bringing this area to the forefront of modern theory again. Brilliantly pushing back against the presumption that religion has become secularized under neoliberalism, Singh provides vivid and extraordinarily well-written ethnographic evidence of how a difficult religious ritual in India-the pilgrimage-is enmeshed and inextricable from late capitalism's efforts to justify and sustain itself. This is a must read for anyone interested in social movements, religion, and social theory in or outside the academy."-Lynn S. Chancer, Hunter College and the Graduate Center of the City University of New York "A provocative attempt to highlight and theorize popular religious practice for social scientists interested in the psyche, the state, and the economy....[T]his insightful book is an important contribution to an emerging critical project within the sociology of religion and would be useful for graduate seminars on theory, religion, culture, and even stratification."-Gary J. Adler, Jr., American Journal of Sociology "In this thematically poignant and evocative work, Vikash Singh provides an ethnography of the Kanwar, India's largest annual pilgrimage rite, alongside a running meditation on the place of religion in modern social theory and (continental) philosophy....The book is sure to prove engrossing."-Faisal Chaudhry, H-Socialisms, H-Net Reviews "One of the skilled techniques of the author is to render the examination of this ritual pilgrimage in layers. This sense of "unpeeling an onion" is a common theme in qualitative research. This, interestingly enough, is also one of the experiential modes of religious pilgrimage itself. In this way, the ethnography is like a pilgrimage into the reality and landscape of a group's religious experience, or the "sacred"....Uprising of the Fools will prove to be an important volume in the discussion of how ritual engages the body, the margins of sexuality, pain, ecstasy, and so forth....[It] offers a theoretically rigorous and experientially enchanting (Weberian allusion intended) study of ritual pilgrimage."-Sarah L. MacMillen, <>Contemporary Sociology: A Journal of Reviews "Singh bounces back and forth between vivid descriptions of the pilgrimage and empathic accounts of the Kanwarias' everyday life struggles in a neoliberal economy. Challenging theories of secularism, modernisation, and religious fundamentalism, he thereby skilfully situates the pilgrims, the 'fools' as the term bhola and the resentment against the Kanwar suggests, in post-colonial capitalism....Uprising of the Fools is a rich ethnography of the Kanwar pilgrimage and offers a timely critical engagement with epistemologies surrounding religion."-Eva Ambos, Asian Journal of Social Science
